THE OFFICIAL NARRATIVE

At the September 14, 2026 city council meeting, Ludington City Manager Kaitlyn Aldrich offered her report on the investigation of several complaints of offensive odors occurring in the city.  Many of us remember the sewage odors permeating the city's south side for a couple of months back in the spring of 2016, and the City of Ludington's attempts at the time to deflect their culpability in the matter, where eventually the problem was blamed on the city's aging sewage treatment infrastructure.

Here is what Aldrich said this Monday about the latest odor issue, which admittedly has been intermittent and not as severe as the 2016 issues:

Aldrich:  "I have] an update on all of the odor complaints around the city.  We have been working for the last three and a half weeks with the EGLE air quality division they've released one report so far.  Tthat report basically summarizes something that none of us really want to hear and that is one of the primary odor complaints around the city is the rotting of the lakeshore vegetation and the general lakeshore and the wind direction that we have been dealing with and the lack of a wind that we have been dealing with for primarily the month of August that was a significant part of their findings.

They have come out and done three separate visits at the wastewater treatment plant; at this point in time the wastewater treatment plant has been ruled out as a source of the odor complaints.  We do have one of our (I believe) annual inspections at the wastewater treatment plant on Wednesday with a separate division of EGLE so they will be doing their normal inspection.  I don't know if they're going to find anything different than what the air quality division says.

There is something unique noted that the air quality division that I reported to them some folks
from Whitehall Industry reported to them at the Pere Marquette industrial park and that is an
ammonia smell near Consumers Energy and the Whitehall industry corner there, kind of across the
street from the wastewater treatment plant.

The air quality division went out. They inspected the businesses. No one is using any cleaning chemicals. They're not sure where it's coming from. All of the businesses have EGLE's contact information. Again, it's separate from the wastewater treatment plant we don't use a chemical like that.  It's very isolated to that corner of the road, could it be in a drain could it be spilled somewhere we don't know but that is isolated.

And then there are some complaints that seem to be specific to Great Lakes Castings that The EGLE
air quality division is investigating too. So I know that air quality has been a huge complaint,
especially on social media.  I would love to say that there is a one-size-fits-all answer. EGLE's Air
Quality Division, there is no special meter. [There] is no special test, a strip that they can run around with.

It is literally using their nose. I have driven around with them for six to eight hours in the last three
weeks. And by myself, with Andy Larr, with other DPW staff, with the fire department, trying to isolate where these smells are coming from, watching wind direction, watching wind speed, it's kind of an all hands on deck.

I wish I had a better answer. It seems to be coming from multiple sources. We're tracking it down the best that we can. The best thing to do, and I already have it in a public service announcement, that's on our website, and the Mason County Press has posted it as well.

If you have an odor complaint, call John Lenio from the Utility Maintenance Department here at the
City. If he doesn't answer, leave him a voicemail.  We're trying to track it, track all the separate complaints, and then we're communicating that.  Isolated data to the air quality division so we can try to get a better handle on maybe where things are coming from..."

ANALYSIS OF THE OFFICIAL LINE

Frankly, this city manager hasn't had a good record of ensuring trust in the past, choosing to not tell the truth on multiple occasions, giving her the nickname of "PrevariKaitlyn".  Without more data, we cannot affirm that she has done that here, but there are signs that she is at least prevaricating in order to shift any blame away from the City of Ludington.

She first offers rotting lakeshore vegetation as a possible source, a convenient bugbear to blame the smell on since it absolves the city of what would be a natural source.  Why does she claim this was something we didn't want to hear, when it's exactly what will cost the city and its taxpayers the least amount to correct?  But wait, why would there be rotting vegetation along the waters in the first place, that typically only occurs when high water levels and/or heavy inland rains flood coastal wetlands, killing and tearing loose native grasses, followed by them being there for a period of time? 

What makes this a ludicrous theory is that Lake Michigan water levels over the last two have been at their lowest over the last decade and there has been zero local flooding events over this summer.  In 2026, rotting vegetation problems have not been reported anywhere we can find in any of the Great Lakes or harbors.  If this was a real cause, the bigger issue would be what is killing off the vegetation in such numbers and where are those rotting piles.  Why can't they be located just by following your nose and why haven't fisherfolk noticed these stagnant piles of rotting vegetation?

In true PrevariKaitlyn fashion, she then declaratively rules out the wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) in one sentence, then speculates that a WWTP inspection coming up should verify that certainty she spoke of.  She later admits that EGLE is not using any special equipment to determine what's causing the odor, just their nose, an instrument belonging to each Ludington resident and visitor that I know of.  

Her mention of Great Lakes Casting seems to be more of a diversion.  Anybody who has the chance of being in that area when there is a downdraft and you are downwind from the facility in operation will know the origin and cause of that oppressive metallic odor.  The city manager seems to be conflating that stench with another odor that seems to center around the WWTP area, she does the same tactic by mentioning the two businesses across the street from the WWTP as potential suspects.  This is classical deflection used mostly by people who want to hide the truth.

THE WITNESSES

This reporter has not been able to experience the smell himself.  I have heard directly from a couple of sources, employees of a factory in the WWTP area, that they were fairly convinced that a very bad odor was coming from the WWTP as their experience had the stink intensify around that area and diminish as they went away from it, this was noticed within the last week.  

More witnesses were reported about at the MCP regarding odors noticed on August 21st, their complaints prompted that investigation by EGLE's air quality division, with Aldrich reporting that nothing conclusive was determined.  On social media, the people seem to believe otherwise, this one a day before the meeting:

Other concerns have been raised on other Ludington-based sites over the last two months.  These reports don't seem to be universally recognized by Ludington citizens and seem to be unverified by officials of EGLE, but Aldrich's words appear to suggest that there is substance to these stench complaints and the city's first goal is to once again deflect blame on sources other than themselves.  Witnesses, on the other hand, seem to be clear in their contentions of the WWTP being the prime suspect.

Readers, over the last two months have you experienced any strong, bad odors in any section of the city or in PM Township?  Have you had opportunity to trace where its source was?  What did it smell like?  Please let us know in the comments.

Views: 521

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

One thing to consider is that since COVIDiticus, many humans have had their sense of smell altered. Many humans completely lost their sense of smell for some time or indefinitely. When and if it returns their can be variations.

RSS

© 2026   Created by XLFD.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service